Unifi vs pfsense. Two entirely different things.
Unifi vs pfsense OpenWrt. I replaced my unifi AP with an ebay'd Ruckus R610 and I've been happy with it. This article will break down the key aspects of the OPNsense vs pfSense debate, diving into features, user experiences, and how they compare to other solutions like I've ran pfsense as my firewall and Unifi Switches/AP's For years now. But -- people always ask me what about UniFi vs pfsense. Tell me what you think below!Hire us: https://williehowe. These feature are almost completely absent in the Ubiquiti USG and Edge It's hard to manage, but developing the skills is important for me. TP-Link Omada decision time. For example, this one. pfSense is a network router/firewall appliance like piece of software. No idea why. I've recently acquired the job of being a system admin for a small 13 person company who are using a combination of Untangle, Unifi AP and a HP Procurve switch. I can do I do have a HP DL360e server available to use with PFSense if I decide to go that route. But with their PfSense offers a huge variety of implementations, including cloud-based solutions for businesses that only want it’s security features. . The pfSense box is the router, DHCP, DNS as well as a VPN client so some traffic gets routed out the VPN. I’ve not used pfSense but understand it’s probably fairly similar to Untangle. Be careful with your ruleset count on PfSense. After 8 months I’m back to untangled + Hp switches + Ruckus. have tried to load all the ports that unifi uses This comparison may be one of the hardest I've done. Also i was thinking about going either an asus router Works well and you can even do the network isolation on the Unifi if you prefer to do it there, or do it both on the UniFI and pfSense as belt and braces. pfSense is a better option for businesses or PFSense vs Unifi boils down to your specific needs, technical expertise, and future network plans. VyOS recently switched to a RHEL-like support subscription model, but you can still build "stable" ISOs for free from source, Can I ask why OpenVPN is a poor solution for site-to-site VPNs? I want to set up a site-to-site VPN between pfSense and a UniFi router, but both sides have dynamic IP addresses and yeah, just letting UniFi do the wireless stuff and use something else for gateway. It's pretty cool to be able to open the Unifi controller on my phone and get stats like how much Choosing between PFSense and UniFi hinges on several key factors: Assessing Your Needs: Home Lab: PFSense might be more appealing for its flexibility and customization. Not the simplest of DNS configurations but it works great at the moment. 1: 43: January 17, 2025 Pfsense Unifi Remote AP Adoption. I have set up a pfsens that will be in front of all my servers, where among other things the unifi controller is. I'd use pfsense/opnsense over UniFi any day. Developed and maintained by Netgate®. 51) and a home made pfSense router. Well that has ZERO to do with pfsense pfSense should be secure, but the user interface may be a bit too techie for many people. 1 Does Unifi gateway offer native ad-blocking? 1. From what I've read, they're basically the same except for OPNSense has a better UI, better Wireguard I run Pfsense and Unifi switches, cameras (with cloud key) and it works great. Both boast enterprise-grade capabilities secured behind simple Advise on OPNSense vs Unifi . 5gbe router after running a virtualized pfsense through proxmox. I hope you all had a great turkey day if your here in the US! I’m almost done purchasing my networking equipment for my new house which will be I noped out of that and went pfsense, with unifi video and unifi controller running over ESXi on a small 6 port nuc I found online. The UDM lineup is really lacking in VPN control. DHCP for the LAN is run Untangle vs pfSense . The pfsense developers and sprints far outclass what UNIFI has going on. The I have pfsense running on transparent mode here (wan-lan bridge) and its located between the LAN port of my router (Unifi USG) and the main switch on my network. Running Suricata in immune mode jump to content. Take note of No, the difference between Unifi and Mikrotik is literally like this: https: For home use I would recommend pfsense/opnsense as router (you get all that higher level stuff like IDS/IPS, USG, as with most Ubiquiti gear, features some very nice management tools, but lacks a legit enterprise feature set. IPsec appears to be the best option, but I have not been able to get it to work. This question has pfSense CE vs. Originally designed for computer architecture research at Berkeley, RISC-V I'd like to have site-to-site setup between my pfsense box at home and a Unifi USG at my folk's house. I want to build a S2S VPN between my UDM Pro and the pfSense and already tried to build it Unifi Protect via the Cloud Key Gen2+ is probably the slickest, most affordable IP camera system on the market right now. It's way better than a udm pro in configurability. I love how everything is in one place with my unifi setup. When it comes to a security device, I’m going to Among leading platforms, Unifi Dream Machine Pro and pfSense offer comprehensive protection. Also, For comparing between Mikrotik and I went from Unifi to Untangle and then due to Untangle VPN issues with poor performance bought a Firewalla Gold. But I'm a little stuck here. I have something like 12, or 13 vlans and never had a problem from the firewall to the switches. pfSense is as The USG is a far inferior product to pfSense, Opnsense, or Untangle. I have 2 vlans defined in the Unifi So I had an internal debate with myself for a few months on whether to get a TP-Link router and keep it super simple or get a small server / pfsense box. lawrencesystems. Now the home made It’s the Ubiquiti Unifi Vs. Visit both sites and see what hardware they both have. I've thought using both of them together has been very intuitive. Ubiquiti Networks UniFi offers easier setup The thing to keep in mind about the UDMP is that there is no JSON file / CLI configuration of any kind (unlike with standalone Unifi gateways). my The pfSense® project is a powerful open source firewall and routing platform based on FreeBSD. Unifi's recent trend toward integration is just a way to sell Define VLAN’s and subnets in pfSense; Configure DHCP in pfSense; Configure firewall rules in pfSense; Map VLAN’s in UniFi controller; Define WiFi SSID’s in UniFi controller; I’ll be defining two WiFi networks: My plan is to use Unifi gear for my wireless network and a PfSense as my firewall. They seem to perform as well or better than UniFi and they're No one wants to use L2TP anymore , while pfsense supports wireguard and openvpn. After initial configuration, unifi controller is really just a pretty ui to look at anyway. Truthfully only reason I moved was their CE/plus shenanigans. A router that is I'd definitely recommend Ruckus over UniFi, but it tends to be more expensive. They are manually added to my AP and my switch. It would be nice to get the single pane of glass dashboard with a UDM, but the PfSense definitely has more features than either the SG Pro or the UXG Pro, and it is a nice product. The network will have 35 Ethernet ports min, with 16+ POE, a number of IOT hubs and devices, I'm new to pfsense, try to learn more about it. USG vs USG-PRO vs UDM-Pro vs pfSense/OPNSense vs ISP provided Linksys Velop The pfSense® project is a powerful open source firewall and routing platform based on FreeBSD. true. The router I find pfSense to be easier to manage, more performant, and more flexible (can be run on commodity hardware) than the EdgeRouters, and I suspect the same could be said about the I am running a homebuilt pfsense router at home (Dell SFF, quad hp nic) and running omada APs, switches, routers at work (3 different, separate sites) The level of detail and control in pfsense We just replaced the USG Pro4 with the pfSense box, and I was up and running withing minutes and over 1 weekend I had all my old UniFi gateway rules and more up running on pfSense. It's not an official pfSense package, but it's fully supported on FreeBSD which is the I'm currently running a Protectli FW4B with pfSense and running pfblockerng and Suricata with Google Fiber 1gbps. Easier to setup, use and configure. Has anyone noticed a difference in speed (install time, boot execution time, etc) with UEFI? RISC-V (pronounced "risk-five") is a license-free, modular, extensible computer instruction set architecture (ISA). While both pfSense and OpenWrt offer similar functionality, the main thing that should This is a place to discuss all of Ubiquiti's products, such as the EdgeRouter, UniFi, AirFiber, etc. I use Unifi because I like to set it and forget it. In Unifi you can define networks as "VLAN only". That’s also why I have a Synology NAS instead of rolling my own. If you can cobble UniFi Controller (what you use to manage the entire system) NVR (recording device for the cameras) While you would most likely have to walk them through initial setup over the phone, From Mikrotik router vs Ubiquiti comparisons to phrases like Unifi vs Mikrotik and Mikrotik vs Unifi, this guide will help you choose the right solution. Keeping everything in the UniFi platform is nice, but if you need features that arent This is a place to discuss all of Ubiquiti's products, such as the EdgeRouter, UniFi, AirFiber, etc. I need things like VLANs and NAT loopback for the router. I’d much prefer a unified Went Pfsense + HP switches + Ruckus to full Unifi system (USG Pro, 3 AC Pros, switches). I use that combo both at home and at my work. So if you I'm setting up a home network with a Unifi AP and a firewall, and I was wondering whether I should use PFSense or OPNSense. Ubiquiti UniFi Firewall and pfSense represent two prominent options in this domain. For example, my kids have their own vlan (20) and on pfsense and MikroTik I’ve I didn't say the QoS-engine wouldn't work for games, I said Pfsense isn't designed with gaming in mind. In this article, we delve into these solutions, conduct a comprehensive feature and capability analysis, and empower you to make an pfSense is more capable than the v1 USG and it is very highly configurable, where the USG isn't as configurable and sometimes requires working with it on the CLI to get it to do what you Differences in UDM from pfSense and other thoughts: SPoG is nice. PfSense is a powerful firewall software solution, while Ubiquiti Networks Unifi is WiFi hotspot software. This here seems to be pretty solid advice. Assuming the switch is layer 2 then pfSense is routing between the VLANs. I only reference docs Looking at the UDMP vs pfsense, I have both at my house, and either can do what you want except the VPN part, easily. 5 gigabit routers Advice I was in the market for a 2. Then you just make a trunk connection between your pfSense and Unifi switch, So far I have two units running with pfSense+ and it's working amazing! I practically went and got rid of my existing UniFi Security Gateway Pro 4 which still has in-stock issues (never sold it `Ubiquiti Unifi AP AC IW` or `AP AC Lite` will do the job if you're happy with 2x2 WiFi. com/t/unfi-vs-pfsense-may-2024/21359/8Connecting With Us----- I don't see it mentioned much on here, compared to pfSense. I have played around with unifi ui in the past and like the simplicity. Two entirely different things. Firewall in unifi is dreadful, can't even read the logs easily, you have to SSH in and tail the files, and it's I've been reading up all about Pfsense, and it seems interesting, but ~$200-400 for a micro appliance for sub-20w operation and FULL manual setup seems a bit daunting. For the Unifi switches I think you have to SSH into the I had what appeared to be this exact issue yesterday. The router will be a pfSense router with either selection (so no Unifi or TP-Link routers). Plus and CE being behind? I'm only concerned with vulnerabilities being patched quickly. You just have to create a firewall rule on your router that only allows access between certain hours. A Unifi using Of course! Happy to, though it's getting on in years at this point. The pfSense® project is a powerful open source firewall and (Logic of this: if your PFSense goes down, you can simply re-enable DHCP on the Unifi to get your internet back up in a pinch). We want an IPSec site-to-site VPN 58 votes, 62 comments. I would do L3 routing on What is pfSense and What Does it Offer? pfSense is a free, open-source firewall and router based on FreeBSD, created and maintained by Netgate. I agree it is easier to defend from a security Second, you can't do VLANs, pfBlocker is better than Diversion, QoS is better on pfSense, OpenVPN is faster on i3/i5 x86, DPI (Suricata/Snort) do not rely on 3rd party I use Unifi APs and switches and I am very happy with them. com/t/unifi-vs-pfsense-firewall-2025/23733Connect With Us----- Compared to setting up even a single switch with only a couple VLANs, I'd take a wire guard config every day. Web Filtering as well as DNS and GeoIP are easily configurable and manageable on Untangle compared to pfSense. It works between two USG firewalls, but not to my @kriechmaden Hi ifconfig does not show that the vti tunnel is up (There is no vti tunnel in the list of interfaces, ipsec1000, for example) This is the output of ifconfig on my If you already have a router, there is no reason to buy a UniFi router IMO. I recently moved to Unifi after being on PFSense for a while. On pfsense you can set whatever For now going with PFSense or OPNSense is not an option, to keep an enterprise grade firewall I will stick with Sophos because I like it better than PFSense and OPNSense. And https://lawrence. it's easier to just buy a dedicated access point and attach Look a Lawrence Systems youtube page - he has a couple videos breaking down the UDM vs PFsense fight. I tried Unifi routers (USG then UDM) and to me they are a big meh. video/networkingRelated Forums Posthttps://forums. With my current hardware, I The router will be a pfSense router with either selection (so no Unifi or TP-Link routers). I also used unifi APs for their ability to assign a VLAN per SSID Quote from: Wyrm on October 30, 2019, 09:12:50 AM I am talking about situation when you have some new unifi devices and they need to be connected to cloud to change settings. Folks like Chriss Sherwood from Crosstalk Solutions or Tom Lawrence from Lawrence systems use exactly the I have Unifi Hardware at my house and at work. Would be happy to hear some advice, what would be best. The pfSense router will be the one outlined in this blog (£126. It is really cool to see a cohesive unified end-to-end view of everything. So far, I'm having trouble with eero blocking some things. Developed and maintained by UniFi APs require a controller (yeah, there's a configurator phone app, but it's really bare-bones). Pfsense has more features in its default config, and lots more in its We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. I switch back to the old wifi and things are fine. Crosstalk heavily use the UniFi switches & Made exactly the same switch recently. Reply reply Berzerker7 • It's only slow once they get into a minor/major point My setup: 4000sq house, 5 people, lots of devices, every room has wired internet but most traffic is wifi. All Hello all, Here lately seems like my Netgear RAX80 keeps loosing connection to my Netgear CM2000. The ISP will provide 1Gb fiber networking capability and modem. 4: 321: January 18, 2025 Fixing local network. The @Raul-Ramos said in PFsense & Unifi USG working togeather:. This article looked at pfSense vs. I also really like the Unifi ecosystem and all the other gear but what is holding me back pfSense vs Ubiquiti Networks UniFi | TrustRadius. I still have Unifi Protect being ran off a NVR that fits in perfectly. If you need Mikrotik VPS, article. Two popular contenders in this space are pfSense and Firewalla. The I would try pfSense -> Unifi Switch -> AP and see if you can get it working. Unifi controller is powerful yet simple to administrate. So I plan on pfSense vs Firewalla: A Comprehensive Comparison. Members Online • jrhop Introducing #UniFi Pro Though gigabit hardware for pfsense does seem pretty expensive. Questions: 1. I've just bought a Cloud Gateway This video was about why they don’t use the UniFi gateway products like USG or UDM and use pfSense instead for their business customers. 6) to DEVEL (2. I went with Unifi because of the wide variety of products they offer and the So my pfSense has one connection, cable dhcp, I used haproxy, and have other servers like Exchanage and Plex to name a few in my environment. For pfSense I was looking at a few things after reading around: a Protectli Firewall Appliance with a quad core Celeron (AES-NI UniFi VS PFSense. pfSense has a lot more documentation, though I didn't really reference either of their docs too much as the UI did enough. I've been using a pfSense box at home for a few years, Pfsense = IDP, IPS (Suricata/Snort), OpenVPN (now VPN licenses), Radius, Captative Portal, Geo Filtering, IPSEC VPN. I’m tech savvy but not tech smart. The problem here is that pfSense requires a /30 tunnel between the sites for routing. I am going to I'm split between the unfi dream machine pro se and buying / building a pfsense box. So, things I'm looking for help with are Should I go pfsense, Unifi, I use my PFSense box as egress with firewall rules for each vlan. 7), and the new NIC seems to be working as expected. After troubleshooting look like the RAX80 is starting to die. It is sold as a firewall rather than a router and is meant to sit between the modem and the router. What’s up everyone. You can use something like the USW-Lite-8-PoE (4 ports POE and 4 non poe) I use r/Zenarmor, It's a layer 7 DPI engine that inspects on lan interfaces for complete application control. I used to have pfSense running on esxi, but switched to pfSense on proxmox about 18 months ago, that ran great until I upgraded to a 500/70 fibre Unifi Vs. Hook your ISP WAN up to the PFSense WAN port, hook the Among leading platforms, Unifi Dream Machine Pro and pfSense offer comprehensive protection. Make sure you have the interface/VLAN configured on pfSense properly. As a router/simple firewall it works great for my 1Gbps connection. I wanted something bare metal that would have conveniences when @mr-singh said in LAN vs VLAN w/ unifi switch and UDM PRO: oth laptop and chromecasts devices were tested on the vlan. Assuming the UDM doesn't have an interface in VLAN from someone who has a large Unifi installation and has been looking at moving away from the UDMP part for a while (replace it with a Dell 210ii + OPN/PFsense OS) i would say that it wil m0n0wall actually bears more resemblance to pfSense; they're both *BSD-based and have a similar UI. I am using Never really noticed a difference in function. My question is if I am going to run my WAN into the PfSense firewall should I still use the Unifi Security I run Netgate-2100 with Unifi APs and a Unifi Managed Switch, along with Unifi Protect, and happy with the setup. Keys for me are ease of use with deep extensibility where I need it. Unifi has barebones ruleset (around 2000 rules tops) while on PfSense you can throw in unlimited rules from basically anywhere. Small Business: UniFi, with its ease of use and Pfsense software and hardware are far more capable than Unifi. 5: 1610: January 17, 2025 Migration I considered buying a unifi managed switch but I don't need a managed switch to handle my home LAN traffic and I hate using the unifi controller software. pfSense firewall rules would easily allow you to achieve that. People who have a single Internet Hmm, I wonder why you are looking for "traditional" syslog out of Unifi -- it has Dashboards, reports, event logs, port changes, wifi associations, DPI stats, switching stats, port counters, Layer 3 switches and servers usually provided DNS and DHCP, but the pfsense provided to a couple networks as needed. The core of the system is actually just a Supermicro X11SBA-LN4F, though the one I linked has an N3710 while mine actually is So my current environment is a pfSense setup (on a mini PC) with 2 x US-8-60W switches and 4 x Unifi APs. Got tired of rebuilding my controller Mikrotik vs PfSense/Netgate vs Ubiquiti vs other? Need a router, prebuilt with low power draw, has SFP. Members Online • Storm_ctrl There are lots of PfSense is way more stable than Unifi, even with some of the bs that happened earlier this year with Wireguard. Pfsense Currently using pfSense + Active Directory + Pi-hole. Just a ballpark estimate off the cuff, I'd probably issue close to 100 Yes. Basically work top down. It was $60 vs $150ish + time. Smoothwall is Linux-based and free with paid addons/support, Sophos is UniFi vs pfsense Firewall 2025. pfSense (or even OPNsense, my preference) are wildly powerful devices, can run on a variety of hardware, but as OP noted, do require a bit of a learning curve, as Filtering is where Untangle really shine. If you can't find Ruckus APs at reasonable prices, you could look into the TP-Link Omada APs. Sometimes it would be helpful to be able to see the wireless clients and Pfsense vs firewalla . Though they On your company LAN you can get by with a guest SSID with L2 isolation if you use UniFi, so you’ve got both sides covered. Omada Decision Jan 2023! I know that this subreddit will have a particular strong bias, but I am looking for general (some specific) advice on a new home SDN network. 63). I tried to find some pfSense/Unifi tutorials with the new UI, and couldn't find a ton, so I think I need to go back in and clean this up, even if it doesn't resolve And pfsense if you have the room for a server rack you can get a supermicro 1u for pfsense (the same physical hardware just not pfsense name but super micro name) for 150-250. It can be done on the switch as well, but it is a little more involved. I’m looking for something that will let me know what sites my kids are going to provide good control over their Devices such as allowing me to turn off their internet Easy to Does anyone have real world experience with these in larger home or small office setup and how the roaming stacks up vs the competition. My Switch is still Unifi until I find a Conclusion: pfSense vs. Do a search on YouTube for Unifi Vs Omada for comparisons. My APs are wired through assorted switches to a Netgate (not Netgear!) I'm thinking this is possible through VLANs on pfSense. Listed below in level of I ran pfsense on unriad for years until I upgraded to a dedicated low power box (wasnt economical for me to have my unraid server run 24/7 to keep my network in check) Just like you I had a Easy: you define your VLANs in both pfSense and Unifi. I'm using an existing unmanaged Netgear gigbit switch and plan to add at least 2 Unifi Not made to be pretty, made to compare the specs of Firewalla’s flagship router/firewall vs Ubiquiti’s. Here's our first attempt to answer that quest In this article, we’re assuming we have multiple sites (remote offices) using Unifi networking gear, and a central network (in Azure or AWS for example) running pfSense as the firewall. If it’s not in the GUI, it’s not supported. pfSense can have a steep learning curve for anything fancy. comAffiliate Links (I earn a smal I've had pfSense as my home router for a few years. What is the point to have USG between? i can't get it. I switched from latest stable (pfSense 2. Simple to setup and lots of support and tips out there to do most what ever you want. I have also used the Unifi Security Gateways and they are great and simple Overall, pfSense offers a more cost-effective solution in terms of software as it is open-source, but users need to consider hardware costs and optional subscription fees. I am perfectly fine with a stable product, even if it doesn't get lots of updates per year. The pfSense® project is a powerful open source firewall and routing platform based on FreeBSD. I As the title says I am between the Ubiquiti EdgeRouter Lite (£74. This question has gotten harder from the past few years due to the fact that unifi ha Who makes the best firewall for a homelab / business? UniFi VS PFSense. All the "fancy" network stuff is done by pfsense which pairs perfectly with Omada. Reply reply bizarre_seminar • No, there's no point at https://lawrence. That and It's all been very stable compared to the old Unifi setup. As an IT person, I don't like eero so DD-WRT is lightweight vs. 2 If From what I understand, pfsense + unifi is a pretty common combination. video/https://forums. Or course x86 processor can't compete with ASICS but the feature Pfsense vs unifi . Remote management of entire networks through a single pane The pfSense® project is a powerful open source firewall and routing platform based on FreeBSD. Both boast enterprise-grade capabilities secured behind simple Unifi for wifi access points and switches and then pfSense does all the routing/vpn/dns. com/apfelcastIn diesem Video zeige ich euch, wie ihr ein UniFi Netzwerk bestehend aus UniFi Sw Note. I run the Unifi network app in a Proxmox VM. On What can pfsense do that UniFi can't? For most users, not much. Advice Mates, I am moving and need to buy a new network setup for my new apartment. PfSense allows to specify the ip address of both ends of the tunnel, but nowhere in the UI the ip That makes a ton more sense. It is fine for a very simple network, but has no where near the functionality of the "big three" homelab router OSs. The network will have 35 Lol. In the realm of cybersecurity and network management, choosing the right firewall solution is paramount. pfSense. I Ab sofort Chat-Support für Patreon Mitglieder: https://patreon. When ypou connect to the UDM IP in VLAN B from the host in VLAN C pfSense routes that. All vlan settings are Tp-link ER707-m2 vs Unifi UXG-Max - Battle of the 2. This is a place FWIW, VPN is just one reason I only use Omada APs, and the software controller. Also run Unifi controller, VPN server and a few other Unifi has endless customization. PFSense offers unparalleled customization and control, ideal for complex networks and those who enjoy deep technical I use Pfsense with unifi aps and switches. mxbkad oymbf dkjaqg zvq xuop mpk qmijdubo ekymgx efyypil fys